The Managing Director of my company wants to reduce the workforce. Specifically, he aims to lay off employees who are non-performers or under-utilized in order to cut costs due to the company's lack of significant profits. The management has tasked me with developing a strategy for this process and outlining the steps that need to be taken after identifying the employees to be laid off.
The layoff process must be executed in a manner that minimizes panic and prevents feelings of insecurity among the remaining employees. I invite everyone to share their input on this matter.
From India, Delhi
Acknowledge(1)
Amend(0)
8The layoff process must be executed in a manner that minimizes panic and prevents feelings of insecurity among the remaining employees. I invite everyone to share their input on this matter.
From India, Delhi
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
Are the non-performers from the Workman Category or other than the worker category? Specifically for worker category, you need to conduct a domestic inquiry before terminating any Workman. For other staff members, please follow the principles of natural justice so that there is no panic situation.
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(1)
Amend(0)
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
Dear Shweta,
Once confirmed, every employee receives protection of employment, which can either be statutory or under the contract of employment, or both, depending on his/her cadre. Therefore, no employer can simply dismiss them under the pretext of surplusage or underperformance at their discretion.
There is no mention of the total number of employees in the organization with a category-wise breakdown. There are two lawful options before the management. One is retrenchment, and the other is voluntary separation.
Retrenchment
In the case of retrenchment, if the average number of employees in the cadre of "workman" as defined under section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, in the preceding 12 months is 100 or more, the employer has to obtain prior permission from the appropriate Government under section 25N. Even if it is less than 100, one month's notice or one month's pay in lieu thereof, and retrenchment compensation at 15 days' wages last drawn for every completed year of service have to be paid by the employer. Moreover, the management cannot pick and choose the people for retrenchment. It should be strictly based on seniority only, i.e., the juniors should be sent out while the seniors are kept. Getting Government permission for retrenchment is a cumbersome quasi-judicial process because it involves the employees or their unions as well. That apart, no popular Government would grant permission for fear of adverse criticism.
Voluntary Separation
Therefore, the better and easily workable option is voluntary separation, provided your management is willing and can afford it. However, the possible inherent downside in VRS is that the less productive employees may stay while some efficient ones may opt to leave. It depends on how you tolerate poor performance, document it, and reward efficient ones.
From India, Salem
Acknowledge(7)
Amend(0)
Once confirmed, every employee receives protection of employment, which can either be statutory or under the contract of employment, or both, depending on his/her cadre. Therefore, no employer can simply dismiss them under the pretext of surplusage or underperformance at their discretion.
There is no mention of the total number of employees in the organization with a category-wise breakdown. There are two lawful options before the management. One is retrenchment, and the other is voluntary separation.
Retrenchment
In the case of retrenchment, if the average number of employees in the cadre of "workman" as defined under section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, in the preceding 12 months is 100 or more, the employer has to obtain prior permission from the appropriate Government under section 25N. Even if it is less than 100, one month's notice or one month's pay in lieu thereof, and retrenchment compensation at 15 days' wages last drawn for every completed year of service have to be paid by the employer. Moreover, the management cannot pick and choose the people for retrenchment. It should be strictly based on seniority only, i.e., the juniors should be sent out while the seniors are kept. Getting Government permission for retrenchment is a cumbersome quasi-judicial process because it involves the employees or their unions as well. That apart, no popular Government would grant permission for fear of adverse criticism.
Voluntary Separation
Therefore, the better and easily workable option is voluntary separation, provided your management is willing and can afford it. However, the possible inherent downside in VRS is that the less productive employees may stay while some efficient ones may opt to leave. It depends on how you tolerate poor performance, document it, and reward efficient ones.
From India, Salem
Acknowledge(7)+2 more
Amend(0)
In the present environment where PhDs are applying for peon jobs, any layoff will be stressful and create panic.
Legal Considerations for Layoffs
Laying off or retrenching workers will fall under the Industrial Disputes Act. The provisions of the act need to be followed in letter and spirit.
Offering a Golden Handshake
A generous golden handshake can be considered as it will be a one-time expenditure. Identify non-performers and bad workers, and prepare a list. See whether your golden handshake will tempt them. It is not easy to get rid of workers in bulk.
Consultation and Strategy Development
Consult a good labor law consultant available locally in confidence, and prepare a strategy.
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(2)
Amend(0)
Legal Considerations for Layoffs
Laying off or retrenching workers will fall under the Industrial Disputes Act. The provisions of the act need to be followed in letter and spirit.
Offering a Golden Handshake
A generous golden handshake can be considered as it will be a one-time expenditure. Identify non-performers and bad workers, and prepare a list. See whether your golden handshake will tempt them. It is not easy to get rid of workers in bulk.
Consultation and Strategy Development
Consult a good labor law consultant available locally in confidence, and prepare a strategy.
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(2)Amend(0)
Dear Shweta,
Understanding Layoffs and Under-Performance
Two terms are important in your post. One is "lay off" and another is "under-performance." If you wish to remove employees on account of under-performance, then it would be incorrect to term it as "lay off." To refer to the definition of lay off, click the following link: [Special Provisions relating to lay-off, retrenchment and closure under Industrial Disputes Act](http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-137-special-provisions-relating-to-lay-off-retrenchment-and-closure-under-industrial-disputes-act.html)
Handling Under-Performance
Removal of employees because of under-performance is common across the spectrum of industries. However, what matters is whether you had issued warning letters once the under-performance was discovered. There should not be sudden termination. Employees need to be given sufficient chance to improve their performance.
Addressing Employee Concerns
Your concern is that employees may get overwhelmed because of fear or anxiety. However, if you are following the principles of natural justice, then neither is there a need for you to worry nor for the employees. Panic could prevail provided employees feel that there is an environment of injustice in the company. To remove the misplaced fear or anxiety amongst the employees, organizational communication plays a big role. Communicate to them that the leadership of your company values performance and those who attain the standards of performance can have a smooth sail.
Ongoing Process of Performance Management
Going further, removal on account of under-performance should be an ongoing process. You should not wait for everyone's removal at a time. If the removal because of under-performance is a regular feature in the company, then also employees will overcome the fear.
Lastly, please use the correct HR terminology not just while raising queries in the public forum but in regular work also.
Thanks,
Dinesh Divekar
From India, Bangalore
Acknowledge(4)
Amend(0)
Understanding Layoffs and Under-Performance
Two terms are important in your post. One is "lay off" and another is "under-performance." If you wish to remove employees on account of under-performance, then it would be incorrect to term it as "lay off." To refer to the definition of lay off, click the following link: [Special Provisions relating to lay-off, retrenchment and closure under Industrial Disputes Act](http://www.legalserviceindia.com/legal/article-137-special-provisions-relating-to-lay-off-retrenchment-and-closure-under-industrial-disputes-act.html)
Handling Under-Performance
Removal of employees because of under-performance is common across the spectrum of industries. However, what matters is whether you had issued warning letters once the under-performance was discovered. There should not be sudden termination. Employees need to be given sufficient chance to improve their performance.
Addressing Employee Concerns
Your concern is that employees may get overwhelmed because of fear or anxiety. However, if you are following the principles of natural justice, then neither is there a need for you to worry nor for the employees. Panic could prevail provided employees feel that there is an environment of injustice in the company. To remove the misplaced fear or anxiety amongst the employees, organizational communication plays a big role. Communicate to them that the leadership of your company values performance and those who attain the standards of performance can have a smooth sail.
Ongoing Process of Performance Management
Going further, removal on account of under-performance should be an ongoing process. You should not wait for everyone's removal at a time. If the removal because of under-performance is a regular feature in the company, then also employees will overcome the fear.
Lastly, please use the correct HR terminology not just while raising queries in the public forum but in regular work also.
Thanks,
Dinesh Divekar
From India, Bangalore
Acknowledge(4)Amend(0)
Dear Colleague, your interchangeable use of lay-off for termination of services is improper. The ID Act defines lay-off and retrenchment specifically, along with the conditions governing them. Lay-off refers to the temporary suspension of an employment contract for legal and justified reasons, and it does not signify the end of the employer-employee relationship as in the case of termination, resignation, retirement, or retrenchment. Retrenchment involves the discharge of surplus labor and can only be carried out by complying with the provisions of the ID Act/Rules.
Termination due to underperformance requires following a disciplinary action procedure by adhering to the principles of natural justice. It appears that your MD may not be fully aware of his legal obligations and seems to believe he can hire and fire at his discretion.
Regards, Vinayak Nagarkar HR Consultant
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(2)Amend(0)
Termination due to underperformance requires following a disciplinary action procedure by adhering to the principles of natural justice. It appears that your MD may not be fully aware of his legal obligations and seems to believe he can hire and fire at his discretion.
Regards, Vinayak Nagarkar HR Consultant
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(2)Amend(0)
Recommendations for Managing Workforce Reductions
Hey Shweta, I recommend the following:
1. Never mix up non-performance, redundancy, lack of projects, making losses, and restructuring for profit while discussing this topic with management or employees.
2. If you trust your MD and have an excellent rapport, then only continue with this project. My honest suggestion is to act carefully and never become a scapegoat.
3. If you have people classified as 'workmen', a recommendation from your labor law advisor is a must before any further action.
4. As you know well, layoff is the most difficult and painful exercise in India. Once done, the black mark stays forever, and unfortunately, HR will be at the receiving end. It is not ethical to suddenly say, "Hey, you guys are not performing, and I don't have money to pay. So fired."
5. Study the problems, gather all sorts of information to identify the real problem. No sales, no viability, no market, no cash to run the business, etc. Then what? Winding up the business through the proper channel.
6. Restructuring by removing a fraction of employees is pretty tough in India. If it is the wish of the management, as an employee, you have no choice. However, prepare for it with due diligence.
Understanding Management Expectations
6.1 Understand the expectations of management - what is the expected outcome. It could be resizing the firm, saving office space, reducing capital costs by 50%, and so on. Make a statement and start from there.
Performance Appraisal and Separation Process
6.2 If your organization has no formal performance appraisal process, HR cannot announce that Mr. ABC is an underperformer. However, as per the appointment order terms, management can dismiss anybody from employment by giving notice and compensation.
6.3 The standard way of performance-related separation requires regular performance checks, placing underperformers in a periodical PIP (performance improvement program), PIP review, sending the case to a committee for the final decision, and then separation.
There are many rude and unethical practices (unnecessary transfers, blame game, keeping employees idle, not paying salaries on time, pushing for unrealistic targets, etc.) to coerce employees and expel them from the company. I recommend not to follow such unfair practices.
From India, Bangalore
Acknowledge(3)Amend(0)
Hey Shweta, I recommend the following:
1. Never mix up non-performance, redundancy, lack of projects, making losses, and restructuring for profit while discussing this topic with management or employees.
2. If you trust your MD and have an excellent rapport, then only continue with this project. My honest suggestion is to act carefully and never become a scapegoat.
3. If you have people classified as 'workmen', a recommendation from your labor law advisor is a must before any further action.
4. As you know well, layoff is the most difficult and painful exercise in India. Once done, the black mark stays forever, and unfortunately, HR will be at the receiving end. It is not ethical to suddenly say, "Hey, you guys are not performing, and I don't have money to pay. So fired."
5. Study the problems, gather all sorts of information to identify the real problem. No sales, no viability, no market, no cash to run the business, etc. Then what? Winding up the business through the proper channel.
6. Restructuring by removing a fraction of employees is pretty tough in India. If it is the wish of the management, as an employee, you have no choice. However, prepare for it with due diligence.
Understanding Management Expectations
6.1 Understand the expectations of management - what is the expected outcome. It could be resizing the firm, saving office space, reducing capital costs by 50%, and so on. Make a statement and start from there.
Performance Appraisal and Separation Process
6.2 If your organization has no formal performance appraisal process, HR cannot announce that Mr. ABC is an underperformer. However, as per the appointment order terms, management can dismiss anybody from employment by giving notice and compensation.
6.3 The standard way of performance-related separation requires regular performance checks, placing underperformers in a periodical PIP (performance improvement program), PIP review, sending the case to a committee for the final decision, and then separation.
There are many rude and unethical practices (unnecessary transfers, blame game, keeping employees idle, not paying salaries on time, pushing for unrealistic targets, etc.) to coerce employees and expel them from the company. I recommend not to follow such unfair practices.
From India, Bangalore
Acknowledge(3)Amend(0)
As rightly said by others, layoff and retrenchment are two different cases. Your case comes under termination through disciplinary action. Without the issuance of any showcase letter or warning letter, you cannot terminate the employee irrespective of their category.
You need to first understand why the management needs to take this action. Only then can you formulate a different strategy to terminate the employee.
From India, Patna
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
You need to first understand why the management needs to take this action. Only then can you formulate a different strategy to terminate the employee.
From India, Patna
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Options for Workforce Reduction
I will suggest the following options:
1. To go for the VRS, if any performing employee opts for the same, you or management can discuss the matter strategically to retain them.
2. Do not directly remove people. It will create panic among the employees, even though you try to take precautions. During performance appraisals, provide feedback to non-performing employees for performance improvement (PIP). Parameters should be clear for performance and non-performance. Just ensure there is no injustice in terms of favoritism or seniority.
Thanks,
SMJ
From India, Faridabad
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
I will suggest the following options:
1. To go for the VRS, if any performing employee opts for the same, you or management can discuss the matter strategically to retain them.
2. Do not directly remove people. It will create panic among the employees, even though you try to take precautions. During performance appraisals, provide feedback to non-performing employees for performance improvement (PIP). Parameters should be clear for performance and non-performance. Just ensure there is no injustice in terms of favoritism or seniority.
Thanks,
SMJ
From India, Faridabad
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
What is the industry you are in? How many employees are employed, age profile, how long your company exists, and turnover details are fundamentally required to give any advice on this subject. In a strict sense, a layoff is a temporary suspension from employment, and what you actually mean may be a permanent handshake. Reducing manpower is a different subject, and sending out people based on performance is also a different subject.
Sivasankaran
From India, Chennai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Sivasankaran
From India, Chennai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Guidelines for Conducting a Layoff
To proceed with a slow layoff, the idea of removing employees based on poor performance is now yours. However, there are judgments and directions for removals. The "last man to go first" means that recently joined employees with lesser service should be at the top of the removals list, while older employees with more service should be retained in order of priority. Everything should be done while serving a notice and briefing the company's facts. Unless poor performance is addressed, it cannot be solely based on your wishes. No one can deny your company's financial status and the necessity for retrenchment. Please obtain permission from the labor department to legally carry out your company's layoff.
Legal Considerations in Layoffs
Another important point to consider is the saying, "If you want to kill a dog, call it a mad dog." It is advised not to follow such old, crude methods. The universally accepted legal procedure is to obtain permissions from the labor department for the layoff and to follow the "last man first go" procedure.
OK, all the best, Swethaji
From India, Nellore
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
To proceed with a slow layoff, the idea of removing employees based on poor performance is now yours. However, there are judgments and directions for removals. The "last man to go first" means that recently joined employees with lesser service should be at the top of the removals list, while older employees with more service should be retained in order of priority. Everything should be done while serving a notice and briefing the company's facts. Unless poor performance is addressed, it cannot be solely based on your wishes. No one can deny your company's financial status and the necessity for retrenchment. Please obtain permission from the labor department to legally carry out your company's layoff.
Legal Considerations in Layoffs
Another important point to consider is the saying, "If you want to kill a dog, call it a mad dog." It is advised not to follow such old, crude methods. The universally accepted legal procedure is to obtain permissions from the labor department for the layoff and to follow the "last man first go" procedure.
OK, all the best, Swethaji
From India, Nellore
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
ID act central Rules 1957 Rule no.77 seniority list to be prepared before removal. LAST COME FIRST GO. IS THE PRINCIPLE OF retrenchment. ALL LAYOFF S WILL BE PACIFIED THROUGH RETRENCHMENT ONLY.
From India, Nellore
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
From India, Nellore
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Please refer to the appointment letters issued to each employee upon joining your organization. If there is a clause stating any notice period for termination, you may proceed with it. Alternatively, you may refer to the Standing Orders, if applicable to your establishment, for employees whom you would like to release from the company.
Please choose one of the above options to streamline the process for excess or underperforming employees. Undoubtedly, during the rationalization of manpower, there may be panic among all employees. However, as an HR professional, you should organize motivational training sessions, provide sufficient timelines, and then execute the process, which will yield positive results.
In addition, many of our colleagues in this forum have shared insights on the processes of retrenchment and layoffs. These processes can be complex and may result in delays in outcomes.
From India, Telangana
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Please choose one of the above options to streamline the process for excess or underperforming employees. Undoubtedly, during the rationalization of manpower, there may be panic among all employees. However, as an HR professional, you should organize motivational training sessions, provide sufficient timelines, and then execute the process, which will yield positive results.
In addition, many of our colleagues in this forum have shared insights on the processes of retrenchment and layoffs. These processes can be complex and may result in delays in outcomes.
From India, Telangana
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
It is itself an alarm and is always a very difficult situation to handle for both employer and employees. The dismissal of employees on the grounds of non-performance is never an easy decision to make, but you must follow the terms of the employment/appointment letter agreed upon by both parties during proceedings.
Many seniors have provided you with the best solutions and suggestions for your concern above. You also have to follow the directions given by your management, so you may first consider the employment conditions and later speak to management for the best possible options as soon as possible.
From India, Gurgaon
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Many seniors have provided you with the best solutions and suggestions for your concern above. You also have to follow the directions given by your management, so you may first consider the employment conditions and later speak to management for the best possible options as soon as possible.
From India, Gurgaon
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Managing Layoffs: A Strategic Approach
Layoffs are a clear management strategy for handling the profit and loss of any company. To stay within budget and reduce expenses and overheads, this is often done. However, most major corporations plan for this in advance (not as a sudden "pink slip" move).
Benefits and Alternatives
You can add some benefits associated with their compensation and offer employees the option to relocate or re-shuffle through internal job postings. In the event that nothing works out, you always have the choice to decide whom you wish to keep on the payroll. Providing sufficient prior notice not only helps but also supports those who have worked for you and their families.
Thanks.
From India
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Layoffs are a clear management strategy for handling the profit and loss of any company. To stay within budget and reduce expenses and overheads, this is often done. However, most major corporations plan for this in advance (not as a sudden "pink slip" move).
Benefits and Alternatives
You can add some benefits associated with their compensation and offer employees the option to relocate or re-shuffle through internal job postings. In the event that nothing works out, you always have the choice to decide whom you wish to keep on the payroll. Providing sufficient prior notice not only helps but also supports those who have worked for you and their families.
Thanks.
From India
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)CiteHR is an AI-augmented HR knowledge and collaboration platform, enabling HR professionals to solve real-world challenges, validate decisions, and stay ahead through collective intelligence and machine-enhanced guidance. Join Our Platform.
Improving Employee Performance Through Workplace Coaching.pdf
Performance Management Process - Power Point Presentation.pp t
Improving Employee Performance.zip