Incident During Night Shift
I have been working at a US-based MNC since May 2016. During my night shift on July 26, 2017, an HR manager and a safety officer conducted a night round check. They found a security officer and a production executive sleeping. At that time, I was suffering from a toothache and had taken medicine while sitting in a relaxed position. They saw me outside the office and assumed I was sleepy, although I was not asleep. When my colleague called me, I stood up from my chair, and that's when the HR manager and safety officer saw me, assuming I had been sleeping before that.
HR Inquiry and Explanation
The next day, I was called to the HR office to discuss the previous night. I explained that the machines had stopped due to ongoing product cleaning work. They informed me that they would discuss the incident with higher authorities to decide on the course of action. Before this incident, I had not been involved in any misbehavior or received any notices from the employer.
Termination and Resignation
The following day, I was called to the HR office with my reporting manager and informed that the higher authority had decided to terminate my employment due to this incident. They gave me the option to resign if I did not want to be terminated. Feeling scared by the severe action, I followed their instructions and resigned.
Seeking Advice
Now, I feel that the decision was unjust. What can I do?
From India, Vadodara
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)
I have been working at a US-based MNC since May 2016. During my night shift on July 26, 2017, an HR manager and a safety officer conducted a night round check. They found a security officer and a production executive sleeping. At that time, I was suffering from a toothache and had taken medicine while sitting in a relaxed position. They saw me outside the office and assumed I was sleepy, although I was not asleep. When my colleague called me, I stood up from my chair, and that's when the HR manager and safety officer saw me, assuming I had been sleeping before that.
HR Inquiry and Explanation
The next day, I was called to the HR office to discuss the previous night. I explained that the machines had stopped due to ongoing product cleaning work. They informed me that they would discuss the incident with higher authorities to decide on the course of action. Before this incident, I had not been involved in any misbehavior or received any notices from the employer.
Termination and Resignation
The following day, I was called to the HR office with my reporting manager and informed that the higher authority had decided to terminate my employment due to this incident. They gave me the option to resign if I did not want to be terminated. Feeling scared by the severe action, I followed their instructions and resigned.
Seeking Advice
Now, I feel that the decision was unjust. What can I do?
From India, Vadodara
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Understanding the Delicate Position of Night Duty
Your position is very delicate, especially during night duty watch and ward. Like in cricket, anything can happen at any time, and there are no excuses. Whether something is right or wrong, things happen, and your version is often not believed by anyone. We are all human, not robots, so sleeping may happen during duty time. Our concern is only for the gravity of the punishment.
Employment Status and Company Responsibility
Are you directly employed by the company itself, or through a contract security agency? If it's the latter, there may be no option. If it's the former, you belong to the company, and they should reconsider decreasing the final punishment. Actually, the company has no right to compel anyone to give a resignation letter; it's an offense. We don't know what actually happened, but usually, a worker refuses to accept their mistake. Even if they do, management challenges, torn papers, and refusal to receive memos are common. Management should rethink such a final punishment. Luckily, no loss happened at that time, so a final punishment is not necessary, though heavy actions can be taken.
Legal Considerations and Advice
Actually, labor laws and court judgments are against the imposition of termination for such simple causes. Therefore, the ill-fated worker can be immediately advised to approach the labor department or labor court. Monetary benefits can be gained.
From India, Nellore
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
69Your position is very delicate, especially during night duty watch and ward. Like in cricket, anything can happen at any time, and there are no excuses. Whether something is right or wrong, things happen, and your version is often not believed by anyone. We are all human, not robots, so sleeping may happen during duty time. Our concern is only for the gravity of the punishment.
Employment Status and Company Responsibility
Are you directly employed by the company itself, or through a contract security agency? If it's the latter, there may be no option. If it's the former, you belong to the company, and they should reconsider decreasing the final punishment. Actually, the company has no right to compel anyone to give a resignation letter; it's an offense. We don't know what actually happened, but usually, a worker refuses to accept their mistake. Even if they do, management challenges, torn papers, and refusal to receive memos are common. Management should rethink such a final punishment. Luckily, no loss happened at that time, so a final punishment is not necessary, though heavy actions can be taken.
Legal Considerations and Advice
Actually, labor laws and court judgments are against the imposition of termination for such simple causes. Therefore, the ill-fated worker can be immediately advised to approach the labor department or labor court. Monetary benefits can be gained.
From India, Nellore
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Do not resign. Let the management to initiate termination. one as such can’t terminate, if they are doing so, will let you chance to take the legal action.
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Sleeping is not a serious offense; on that basis, any management can't terminate the employee. On the other hand, let's wait for the management decision. If they opt for termination, you can challenge the decision in labor court, or they have to pay the notice period as per your appointment letter.
From India, Panipat
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
From India, Panipat
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Dear Raj,
Please do not resign under any condition. The company cannot terminate your service for sleeping (even if you are disputing it, or even if you admit it, they cannot terminate). This is not a serious misconduct that would warrant termination. Even if the management makes an arbitrary decision to terminate you, they will lose the case in the labor court.
Warm Regards,
Bharat Gera
HR Consultant
9322404765
From India, Thane
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Please do not resign under any condition. The company cannot terminate your service for sleeping (even if you are disputing it, or even if you admit it, they cannot terminate). This is not a serious misconduct that would warrant termination. Even if the management makes an arbitrary decision to terminate you, they will lose the case in the labor court.
Warm Regards,
Bharat Gera
HR Consultant
9322404765
From India, Thane
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)CiteHR is an AI-augmented HR knowledge and collaboration platform, enabling HR professionals to solve real-world challenges, validate decisions, and stay ahead through collective intelligence and machine-enhanced guidance. Join Our Platform.
Amended Labor Laws.doc
Labor Laws Modified.pdf