What is the major diffference b/w Charge Sheet and Show cause notice? Which one we can issue first to the alleged employee? Let me explain full Disciplinary proceedings
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)
16From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Charge sheet is a letter issued by management to the accused employee, informing the details of charges leveled against him indicating the date, time, and venue of the charges done by him. This can be followed by issuing a suspension order and warning letter after the suspension period is over and close the case. Alternatively, issue a warning letter - depending upon the gravity of the misconduct committed by him, and close the case.
As for a show cause notice, you are show causing an employee as to why disciplinary action should not be taken against him (asking for his explanation). After issuing a show cause notice, you can constitute a domestic enquiry and based on the findings of the Enquiry Officer, you can impose penalties, suspension order, or both, or dismissal from the services.
Thanks,
R K Nair
From India, Aizawl
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
As for a show cause notice, you are show causing an employee as to why disciplinary action should not be taken against him (asking for his explanation). After issuing a show cause notice, you can constitute a domestic enquiry and based on the findings of the Enquiry Officer, you can impose penalties, suspension order, or both, or dismissal from the services.
Thanks,
R K Nair
From India, Aizawl
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Basically, there is hardly any difference between these two, though the instance when it is issued will figure out some difference. Both Charge Sheet and Show Cause notice intend to describe the charges leveled against the employee and direct him to show cause why disciplinary action should not be taken against him for the alleged misconduct.
When an employee is found involved in misconduct, it is proper to issue a show cause notice elaborating the charges/misconducts done by him and ask him to reply to it. If the misconduct is very severe, then it is also possible that the employee will be placed under suspension and then issued a charge sheet stating the charges and the grounds on which he has been placed under suspension. Domestic enquiry will take place only when the employee defends the charges and when the reply to the show cause notice is not acceptable to the management.
After the enquiry, based on the enquiry report, the management will decide on the punishment to be awarded to the employee. This is communicated to the employee in the form of a show cause notice, commonly referred to as the second show cause notice, through which the employer will say that the charges leveled against the employee have been proved, and therefore, the punishment as stated will be imposed on him and will call him to show why the said punishment should not be imposed on him. In this case, it is purely a show cause notice whereas in the former case, it is in the form of a charge sheet because it contains charges leveled against the delinquent.
Madhu.T.K
From India, Kannur
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
When an employee is found involved in misconduct, it is proper to issue a show cause notice elaborating the charges/misconducts done by him and ask him to reply to it. If the misconduct is very severe, then it is also possible that the employee will be placed under suspension and then issued a charge sheet stating the charges and the grounds on which he has been placed under suspension. Domestic enquiry will take place only when the employee defends the charges and when the reply to the show cause notice is not acceptable to the management.
After the enquiry, based on the enquiry report, the management will decide on the punishment to be awarded to the employee. This is communicated to the employee in the form of a show cause notice, commonly referred to as the second show cause notice, through which the employer will say that the charges leveled against the employee have been proved, and therefore, the punishment as stated will be imposed on him and will call him to show why the said punishment should not be imposed on him. In this case, it is purely a show cause notice whereas in the former case, it is in the form of a charge sheet because it contains charges leveled against the delinquent.
Madhu.T.K
From India, Kannur
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Thank you for your valuable reply.
I have come to know that some companies are directly issuing a charge sheet instead of a Show Cause Notice (SCN). Is this correct or wrong? Can anyone please share the flow chart for disciplinary action steps as per what the law says?
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
I have come to know that some companies are directly issuing a charge sheet instead of a Show Cause Notice (SCN). Is this correct or wrong? Can anyone please share the flow chart for disciplinary action steps as per what the law says?
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
If the charge sheet contains a direction to the employee to show cause/reply in writing why further action should not be taken, then there is nothing wrong in giving the charge sheet in the first instance itself without giving one show cause notice and then giving the charge sheet. Normally, a charge sheet is prepared taking time since it should be very specific, and there should not be any ambiguity with regard to charges.
Regards, Madhu.T.K
From India, Kannur
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Regards, Madhu.T.K
From India, Kannur
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Mr. Madhu,
Regarding your above reply, I understand that a Charge Sheet can be given directly without any Show Cause Notice, is that correct? If the alleged employee admits to his mistake or misconduct with respect to the charges mentioned in the charge sheet, what would be the next step, considering there is no need to conduct a Domestic Enquiry?
In our company's practice, we directly impose punishment according to our Punishment Matrix based on the charges leveled by the alleged employee. If the employee does not agree, they are temporarily suspended so we can conduct a Preliminary Enquiry with company staff (excluding HR) to ensure fair treatment of the employee. We gather findings from the Preliminary Enquiry Officer, after which the HR head decides on the punishment. Is this approach correct, or do you recommend any modifications?
Please advise.
Satkhi
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Regarding your above reply, I understand that a Charge Sheet can be given directly without any Show Cause Notice, is that correct? If the alleged employee admits to his mistake or misconduct with respect to the charges mentioned in the charge sheet, what would be the next step, considering there is no need to conduct a Domestic Enquiry?
In our company's practice, we directly impose punishment according to our Punishment Matrix based on the charges leveled by the alleged employee. If the employee does not agree, they are temporarily suspended so we can conduct a Preliminary Enquiry with company staff (excluding HR) to ensure fair treatment of the employee. We gather findings from the Preliminary Enquiry Officer, after which the HR head decides on the punishment. Is this approach correct, or do you recommend any modifications?
Please advise.
Satkhi
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
If the employee admits the charges, there is no need to conduct an inquiry, but you can decide on the punishment and impose it. Before imposing punishment, however, you have to issue a show cause notice and ask the employee to show cause why this punishment should not be imposed on him.
The punishment awarded should equate with the same given in your certified Standing Orders or in the absence of standing orders, the punishment matrix, as accepted by the employees in general. If you conduct an inquiry on the charges, the process shall be the same as per your current practice, but as far as possible, the employee should be given adequate opportunity to defend the charges leveled against him. He should be given time to present his case in his favor, allowed somebody from the office to assist him in the inquiry, given reasonable adjournments, etc. Above all, in the first sitting itself, he should be given a list of witnesses and documents the company is going to produce against him or in favor of the charges. As far as possible, copies of the evidence should also be given to him for verification and furnishing a reply.
Punishment can be awarded only by the person who is authorized to appoint an employee.
Madhu.T.K
From India, Kannur
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
The punishment awarded should equate with the same given in your certified Standing Orders or in the absence of standing orders, the punishment matrix, as accepted by the employees in general. If you conduct an inquiry on the charges, the process shall be the same as per your current practice, but as far as possible, the employee should be given adequate opportunity to defend the charges leveled against him. He should be given time to present his case in his favor, allowed somebody from the office to assist him in the inquiry, given reasonable adjournments, etc. Above all, in the first sitting itself, he should be given a list of witnesses and documents the company is going to produce against him or in favor of the charges. As far as possible, copies of the evidence should also be given to him for verification and furnishing a reply.
Punishment can be awarded only by the person who is authorized to appoint an employee.
Madhu.T.K
From India, Kannur
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)Gathering data for an AI comment.... Sending emails to relevant members...
Stuck with an HR fire? Get a verified answer before your next coffee. - Join Our Community and get connected with the right people who can help. Our AI-powered platform provides real-time fact-checking, peer-reviewed insights, and a vast historical knowledge base to support your search.
SHOW CAUSE NOTICE.pdf
Check LisCheck List ofr Disciplinary Proceedings Domestic Enquiry 11 Sep 09.doc