Dear Fraternity,
I hope you're doing well.
We have been maintaining coverage under both ESIC and WC policies for additional security and protection of our employees. However, we’ve encountered a practical issue regarding applicability and claim settlements.
In some past cases where an accident occurred, and we filed a WC claim, the insurance company declined stating that employees covered under ESIC cannot claim WC benefits. However, as per our understanding of the ESIC Act, employers can either opt for ESIC or WC depending on the circumstances—but not both simultaneously for the same claim. We are trying to ensure we remain compliant while still securing proper protection for our workforce.
Now, during this year's WC renewal discussion, the insurer has mentioned that they will only cover accidental expanses in WC for employees who are already covered under ESIC, and no disability or loss of pay benefits would apply.
We would like your expert opinion on:
A. How do we best approach this situation for future claims?
B. Should we continue both policies? Or restructure our approach depending on the employee category (e.g., ESIC-covered vs. non-ESIC-covered)?
C. Are there legal implications in terms of opting for WC in selective cases where ESIC is also applicable?
We seek to remain fully compliant while protecting the interest of our workers in the best possible way. Your guidance will help us make a well-informed decision during this renewal cycle.
From India, Ahmedabad
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)
I hope you're doing well.
We have been maintaining coverage under both ESIC and WC policies for additional security and protection of our employees. However, we’ve encountered a practical issue regarding applicability and claim settlements.
In some past cases where an accident occurred, and we filed a WC claim, the insurance company declined stating that employees covered under ESIC cannot claim WC benefits. However, as per our understanding of the ESIC Act, employers can either opt for ESIC or WC depending on the circumstances—but not both simultaneously for the same claim. We are trying to ensure we remain compliant while still securing proper protection for our workforce.
Now, during this year's WC renewal discussion, the insurer has mentioned that they will only cover accidental expanses in WC for employees who are already covered under ESIC, and no disability or loss of pay benefits would apply.
We would like your expert opinion on:
A. How do we best approach this situation for future claims?
B. Should we continue both policies? Or restructure our approach depending on the employee category (e.g., ESIC-covered vs. non-ESIC-covered)?
C. Are there legal implications in terms of opting for WC in selective cases where ESIC is also applicable?
We seek to remain fully compliant while protecting the interest of our workers in the best possible way. Your guidance will help us make a well-informed decision during this renewal cycle.
From India, Ahmedabad
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
In addressing the situation regarding Workers' Compensation (WC) and ESIC coverage for employees, it's crucial to navigate the legal aspects carefully. Here are practical steps to consider:
1. Review Legal Provisions: Examine the ESIC Act and relevant labor laws to understand the provisions regarding simultaneous coverage under ESIC and WC. Ensure compliance with the legal framework.
2. Consult Legal Counsel: Seek advice from legal experts specializing in labor laws to clarify any ambiguities and determine the best course of action to protect both the employees and the organization.
3. Evaluate Claim Scenarios: Assess past claim settlements and denials to identify patterns and understand the implications of dual coverage. Use this analysis to inform future decisions.
4. Tailored Approach: Consider restructuring the coverage based on employee categories. Evaluate the benefits and drawbacks of continuing both policies versus opting for either ESIC or WC based on individual employee needs.
5. Employee Communication: Transparently communicate any changes in coverage to employees, highlighting the rationale behind the decision and how it benefits their well-being and protection.
6. Continuous Monitoring: Regularly review the effectiveness of the chosen approach and adjust policies as needed to ensure optimal coverage and compliance with labor laws.
By carefully navigating the legal landscape, evaluating claim scenarios, and adopting a tailored approach, you can make informed decisions to protect your employees while ensuring compliance with relevant regulations.
From India, Gurugram
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
541. Review Legal Provisions: Examine the ESIC Act and relevant labor laws to understand the provisions regarding simultaneous coverage under ESIC and WC. Ensure compliance with the legal framework.
2. Consult Legal Counsel: Seek advice from legal experts specializing in labor laws to clarify any ambiguities and determine the best course of action to protect both the employees and the organization.
3. Evaluate Claim Scenarios: Assess past claim settlements and denials to identify patterns and understand the implications of dual coverage. Use this analysis to inform future decisions.
4. Tailored Approach: Consider restructuring the coverage based on employee categories. Evaluate the benefits and drawbacks of continuing both policies versus opting for either ESIC or WC based on individual employee needs.
5. Employee Communication: Transparently communicate any changes in coverage to employees, highlighting the rationale behind the decision and how it benefits their well-being and protection.
6. Continuous Monitoring: Regularly review the effectiveness of the chosen approach and adjust policies as needed to ensure optimal coverage and compliance with labor laws.
By carefully navigating the legal landscape, evaluating claim scenarios, and adopting a tailored approach, you can make informed decisions to protect your employees while ensuring compliance with relevant regulations.
From India, Gurugram
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)CiteHR is an AI-augmented HR knowledge and collaboration platform, enabling HR professionals to solve real-world challenges, validate decisions, and stay ahead through collective intelligence and machine-enhanced guidance. Join Our Platform.
ESIC HANDICAPED EMPLOYEE REGISTRATION-23 0311PhyHEmp.pdf