I have been offered a consultant position at an institute, but the appointment letter mentions pay under the head of gross salary split into basic, TA, and special allowance. Is this technically and legally correct? It also states that 10% TDS will be deducted. In such a case, should I pay the rest of the tax according to the gross pay as self-assessment tax? Will the consultant position establish an employee-employer relationship in this context?
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Dear Sana,
Your client does not know the difference between salary and consulting charges. While the former can be divided into several components like basic, house rent, etc., the latter is a consolidated amount. Anyway, even without understanding the difference, they will be deducting TDS of 10%, which is legally correct. This deduction will be under Section 194J of the IT Act. In your IT assessment, you may show payment of this tax to get the input credit.
Thanks,
Dinesh Divekar
From India, Bangalore
Acknowledge(2)
Amend(0)
8072Your client does not know the difference between salary and consulting charges. While the former can be divided into several components like basic, house rent, etc., the latter is a consolidated amount. Anyway, even without understanding the difference, they will be deducting TDS of 10%, which is legally correct. This deduction will be under Section 194J of the IT Act. In your IT assessment, you may show payment of this tax to get the input credit.
Thanks,
Dinesh Divekar
From India, Bangalore
Acknowledge(2)Amend(0)
Hi Sana2017, it's been a while, and this will probably be my first contribution. I have been reading through the discussions and feel I can provide some insight.
Understanding the Consultant Role
To put it simply, as a consultant, you should have what we can call a 'deed of agreement' or any agreement specifying you as their 'consultant' and the company you are consulting with as the first party. An appointment letter is typically provided if you are under their payroll as an employee. From your post, I sense you don’t work directly under any of the directors or superiors of that company you’re referring to—please correct me if I am wrong.
Role of a Consultant
Consultation, as you know best, involves providing improvement plans and recommending the best solutions available in any pre-existing policies/procedures. It's up to the company's management whether they take it positively or seriously, but if you present it well, they might see a good future plan based on your recommendations. For example, if you are a consultant for a training program and you have surveyed the employees' career plans/paths, in order to retain them in the company and reduce turnover, you may recommend training programs tailored to their needs according to the survey/interviews. This involves costs, of course, and it's up to the company management to determine if your recommendations are feasible.
Tax Considerations
Regarding taxes, I am not familiar with that aspect, but as my suggestion above goes, you only receive consultation fees, and the tax should be paid by you as per your tax declaration.
Good luck and more power!
Regards, Shallohal
Bangladesh
From Bangladesh, Dhaka
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Understanding the Consultant Role
To put it simply, as a consultant, you should have what we can call a 'deed of agreement' or any agreement specifying you as their 'consultant' and the company you are consulting with as the first party. An appointment letter is typically provided if you are under their payroll as an employee. From your post, I sense you don’t work directly under any of the directors or superiors of that company you’re referring to—please correct me if I am wrong.
Role of a Consultant
Consultation, as you know best, involves providing improvement plans and recommending the best solutions available in any pre-existing policies/procedures. It's up to the company's management whether they take it positively or seriously, but if you present it well, they might see a good future plan based on your recommendations. For example, if you are a consultant for a training program and you have surveyed the employees' career plans/paths, in order to retain them in the company and reduce turnover, you may recommend training programs tailored to their needs according to the survey/interviews. This involves costs, of course, and it's up to the company management to determine if your recommendations are feasible.
Tax Considerations
Regarding taxes, I am not familiar with that aspect, but as my suggestion above goes, you only receive consultation fees, and the tax should be paid by you as per your tax declaration.
Good luck and more power!
Regards, Shallohal
Bangladesh
From Bangladesh, Dhaka
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)CiteHR is an AI-augmented HR knowledge and collaboration platform, enabling HR professionals to solve real-world challenges, validate decisions, and stay ahead through collective intelligence and machine-enhanced guidance. Join Our Platform.
How GST complicates employer-employ ee relationship.do cx
Contract employee & Principal employer 2017.pdf