should intern be paid by the company? and waht office time they should work ?
From India, Margão
Acknowledge(0)
Amend(0)
From India, Margão
Acknowledge(0)Amend(0)
Hi Shraddha, if interns are working full-time and truly adding value to the organization, yes, they can be paid. Regarding timing, it should be regular, similar to a full-time employee. The amount depends on the company and how much they can afford for this.
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
70From India, Pune
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
According to my point of view, an internship should be paid. It acts as a motivation, and you can always get their positive response. This makes them responsible for valuable output. The timing depends upon their subject; for example, a marketing person has to survey the market, and for HR, one should be in the office depending on the subject. However, it should not affect office work.
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(2)Amend(0)
From India, Pune
Acknowledge(2)Amend(0)
Paying interns or not is at the company's discretion. Most companies pay interns as it motivates them, while many do not but provide other benefits.
During my internship at a reputed firm, I was not paid for my tenure, despite working normal office hours. However, they compensated by offering canteen coupons, meal vouchers, and additional benefits. This support was more motivating than just a few bucks.
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(1)
Amend(0)
During my internship at a reputed firm, I was not paid for my tenure, despite working normal office hours. However, they compensated by offering canteen coupons, meal vouchers, and additional benefits. This support was more motivating than just a few bucks.
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
To each his own—I think if the company can afford it, it should pay. There is an image impact for companies that employ interns but don't pay. Of course, if the company is very small, it may not be concerned about the negative signals it gives out.
And then, the other question is why do you want to extract work from someone (okay, I know he is an intern and the output wouldn't be as much as an employee) without paying?
From India, Ghaziabad
Acknowledge(1)
Amend(0)
And then, the other question is why do you want to extract work from someone (okay, I know he is an intern and the output wouldn't be as much as an employee) without paying?
From India, Ghaziabad
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
You have found the best ideas and suggestions so far. Here's my question to you: Why would you allow an intern into your office premises for a fixed duration if the intern has no value to add? I wholeheartedly agree; we endlessly complain about how little the interns are equipped to deliver! To an extent, these complaints are empty, as that's only why they are interning. Please find a definite program to employ the interns. Ensure you, as an employer, add value to their careers with learning and experience, as much effort as you may require from them. When there is an exchange of services, it's imperative to pay. Branding as an employer goes a long way. It doesn't always need you to win any award as 'the best employer' to be one, but implement best practices seamlessly. Wish you all the best!
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(4)Amend(0)
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(4)Amend(0)
Very well put by (Cite Contribution) 1979. If they are adding no value, why employ them, and if they are, better pay them. @Shah01ankita
I think "Either you are interested in working or you are running after money" is a lie, though a popular one, spread by evil companies out to exploit interns (okay, much dramatization!). Who says you can't do both—be interested in work plus want to be paid for your hard work? Why is the demand for compensation considered fair for an employee but not for an intern?
From India, Delhi
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
I think "Either you are interested in working or you are running after money" is a lie, though a popular one, spread by evil companies out to exploit interns (okay, much dramatization!). Who says you can't do both—be interested in work plus want to be paid for your hard work? Why is the demand for compensation considered fair for an employee but not for an intern?
From India, Delhi
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
[QUOTE=bodhisutra;2058145]Very well put by (Cite Contribution) 1979. If they are adding no value, why employ them, and if they are, better pay them.
@Shah01ankita
I think "Either you are interested in working or you are running after money" is a lie, though a popular one, spread by companies out to exploit interns (okay, much dramatization!). Who says you can't do both - be interested in work plus want to be paid for your hard work?
Why is demand for compensation considered fair for an employee but not for an intern? I never said it is true for all. That was what was found true for the batch I learned with.
The Real Purpose of the Internship
- To have hands-on experience in a real-life job situation.
- To handle responsibilities under the guidance of a head so that you are able to handle them in the future when you become responsible for it.
When I was told this firm won't pay a penny, I had to take a chance. In my internship, I was actually made to learn a lot of HR things: how HR Auditing works, how employee engagement works, how to give presentations, how employees' grievances are handled. We were always invited and were allowed to take notes in the HR training sessions that were made for employees.
I just wanted to point out that just as you mention why can't it be both, likewise it is not necessary that the companies are looking out for cheap or free labor to get their mandated things done by the so-called interns. Sometimes (of course depending on the firms or perhaps I was too lucky to have experienced this) the firms have contributed to you more than just the money.
Just like a famous quote says - "Some people are so poor. All they have is just money."
All I wanted to say was while choosing an internship, do not go for the company that pays the highest stipend. Instead, go for one that would prepare you for your on-the-job role.
Hope I cleared my view.
Thanks
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
@Shah01ankita
I think "Either you are interested in working or you are running after money" is a lie, though a popular one, spread by companies out to exploit interns (okay, much dramatization!). Who says you can't do both - be interested in work plus want to be paid for your hard work?
Why is demand for compensation considered fair for an employee but not for an intern? I never said it is true for all. That was what was found true for the batch I learned with.
The Real Purpose of the Internship
- To have hands-on experience in a real-life job situation.
- To handle responsibilities under the guidance of a head so that you are able to handle them in the future when you become responsible for it.
When I was told this firm won't pay a penny, I had to take a chance. In my internship, I was actually made to learn a lot of HR things: how HR Auditing works, how employee engagement works, how to give presentations, how employees' grievances are handled. We were always invited and were allowed to take notes in the HR training sessions that were made for employees.
I just wanted to point out that just as you mention why can't it be both, likewise it is not necessary that the companies are looking out for cheap or free labor to get their mandated things done by the so-called interns. Sometimes (of course depending on the firms or perhaps I was too lucky to have experienced this) the firms have contributed to you more than just the money.
Just like a famous quote says - "Some people are so poor. All they have is just money."
All I wanted to say was while choosing an internship, do not go for the company that pays the highest stipend. Instead, go for one that would prepare you for your on-the-job role.
Hope I cleared my view.
Thanks
From India, Mumbai
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
Just to add to the discussion:
- Paying or not paying interns should be governed by company policy, so frame one in your company to avoid such confusions in the future.
- An internship should be viewed as an opportunity for the intern to gain maximum exposure to the business/domain, and he/she should aim to extract the most out of it.
- The company should strive to provide good exposure and possibly a mentor/guide to the intern, attempting to present its professional image as it serves as the intern's first key interface with the corporate world.
- If an intern is being hired for a project, the company should pay.
- Sometimes, to accommodate someone's requests, an internship is offered; in such cases, a company may choose not to pay. Again, it's at the company's discretion. I have seen cases where interns were taken under this category, but as they performed well during their internship, the company decided to pay them at the end. It acted as a feel-good factor for the intern.
- Hence, the decision on the payment amount, timings, etc., can be made after discussions with the company core team. You may create a draft and share it with them. Also, you may categorize institutes and qualifications and decide on different pay ranges for interns from those institutes/qualifications.
Hope this helps.
Thanks!
From India, Hyderabad
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
- Paying or not paying interns should be governed by company policy, so frame one in your company to avoid such confusions in the future.
- An internship should be viewed as an opportunity for the intern to gain maximum exposure to the business/domain, and he/she should aim to extract the most out of it.
- The company should strive to provide good exposure and possibly a mentor/guide to the intern, attempting to present its professional image as it serves as the intern's first key interface with the corporate world.
- If an intern is being hired for a project, the company should pay.
- Sometimes, to accommodate someone's requests, an internship is offered; in such cases, a company may choose not to pay. Again, it's at the company's discretion. I have seen cases where interns were taken under this category, but as they performed well during their internship, the company decided to pay them at the end. It acted as a feel-good factor for the intern.
- Hence, the decision on the payment amount, timings, etc., can be made after discussions with the company core team. You may create a draft and share it with them. Also, you may categorize institutes and qualifications and decide on different pay ranges for interns from those institutes/qualifications.
Hope this helps.
Thanks!
From India, Hyderabad
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
Hi @Shah01ankita (Not really trying to get into a fight with you - appreciate your point much!) Totally agree with you that while selecting an internship, don't go by the biggest bundle of notes. Ditto for jobs.
From an intern's point of view, he should indeed think of the stipend as irrelevant. However, from a company perspective, it is simply not honorable to get someone to work for you and not pay - even if the company is adding much more to the intern than just money.
Some things (in fact, most that matter) are very simple - you ask someone to work for you, you pay. Black and white.
From India, Delhi
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)
From an intern's point of view, he should indeed think of the stipend as irrelevant. However, from a company perspective, it is simply not honorable to get someone to work for you and not pay - even if the company is adding much more to the intern than just money.
Some things (in fact, most that matter) are very simple - you ask someone to work for you, you pay. Black and white.
From India, Delhi
Acknowledge(1)Amend(0)CiteHR is an AI-augmented HR knowledge and collaboration platform, enabling HR professionals to solve real-world challenges, validate decisions, and stay ahead through collective intelligence and machine-enhanced guidance. Join Our Platform.
Company Profile Letter - Global Risk Management Services.pdf