Background Verification for Current Employees: Is It Legal in India? Seeking Your Insights

Hi All, Can "background verification" be done for current employees? Is it legal in India? Looking forward to your responses.

Thanks,
Ananya

Background Verification for Current Employees in India

In India, conducting background verification on current employees is a common practice, and it is legal under certain conditions. However, there are specific guidelines and regulations that must be followed to ensure compliance with labor laws and protect employee rights.

Legal Considerations:
- The process of background verification for current employees must adhere to the Indian labor laws, particularly the Information Technology (Reasonable Security Practices and Procedures and Sensitive Personal Data or Information) Rules, 2011.
- Employers are required to obtain written consent from the employees before initiating any background checks. The consent should clearly outline the scope of the verification process and the information that will be verified.
- It is essential to maintain confidentiality and ensure that the employee's privacy is protected throughout the verification process.

Steps to Conduct Background Verification for Current Employees:
1. Obtain Written Consent: Request employees to provide written consent for conducting background verification.
2. Define Scope: Clearly define the scope of the verification process, including the types of checks to be conducted (e.g., criminal record, employment history, educational qualifications).
3. Engage a Professional Agency: Consider using a reputable third-party agency to conduct the verification process to ensure accuracy and compliance with legal requirements.
4. Verify Information: Conduct the necessary checks while ensuring that the process is transparent and respects the employee's privacy.
5. Document Findings: Maintain detailed records of the verification process and findings for future reference.
6. Communication: Inform employees about the results of the background verification process in a professional and confidential manner.

Key Points to Remember:
- Ensure compliance with labor laws and regulations governing background verification.
- Respect employee privacy and confidentiality throughout the process.
- Maintain accurate records and document the verification process for transparency.

By following the legal guidelines and best practices outlined above, employers can conduct background verification for current employees in India effectively and ethically.

Dear Ananya,

The background checks help employers verify candidates' credentials, education, and work experience, safeguard a business from fraudulent practices, and ensure that the onboarded candidates possess the required skills and qualifications for the job.

Employers can screen the candidate's profile, from education to employment to a criminal history check, to avoid legal trouble and ensure that the workplace is free from any risks or hazards.

To avoid these challenges, companies initiate the background check as soon as the employee joins the company. However, your question appears to be about conducting these checks after some time. How long after the employee's joining would you like to initiate the background checks? Is it that your company did not perform these checks immediately after the employee's joining but wishes to do so later to avoid any audit objections regarding process non-compliance?

Background checks fall outside the purview of labor laws. However, what if the employee's performance is satisfactory or above but they fail in the background verification process? Would you want the employee to resign? If so, wouldn't this action potentially harm the company's reputation?

Is it possible that the relevant authorities aim to dismiss the employee, and the "failure in background verification" is being used as a pretext?

Your post raises several questions. Please provide clarification.

Thanks,

Dinesh Divekar

Dear Ms. Ananya,

Yes, it is legal to perform background verification on current employees in India, provided it is done with their consent and in compliance with privacy laws and regulations. It is crucial to ensure that the process is fair, non-discriminatory, and transparent.

Legal Aspects of Background Verification for Current Employees:

1. Consent: If an employer decides to carry out a background verification of an existing employee, it is essential to get their consent in writing.

2. Privacy Laws: India has data protection laws (although a comprehensive data protection law is still evolving). Currently, the Information Technology (Reasonable Security Practices and Procedures and Sensitive Personal Data or Information) Rules, 2011, along with other data privacy guidelines, govern how personal data should be handled. Employers must ensure that any background verification process complies with privacy and data protection principles.

3. Right to Privacy: Employees in India have a fundamental right to privacy. This means that employers must avoid intrusive verification methods that could violate this right. They need to strike a balance between legitimate business interests (e.g., ensuring security, integrity, and trust) and protecting the privacy of employees.

4. Non-Discrimination: Employers should ensure that background checks do not unfairly discriminate against employees, especially in cases where the information may not be relevant to the employee’s current role or job responsibilities.

5. Fairness and Transparency: Employers should maintain transparency regarding the process and communicate with employees about what kind of background checks will be carried out, how the data will be used, and the consequences (if any) of the verification results.

Thanks and Regards,
Tajun
Team Lead - Talent Acquisition

Dear Ananya,

To understand your query regarding background verification for current employees, I am sharing a case I handled twelve years ago.

Background Verification Case Study

We received an anonymous letter about a person who had worked for over 15 years in a managerial (promotee) position and was a subordinate colleague to me. I was in a fix because the gravity of the complaint was significant, and I was new to the company. This information was immediately shared with the Director HR of my region. The Director HR was also confused about taking action against a person who had been working for 15 years based on an anonymous letter from an unknown sender.

It was decided to ask the person via mail to bring all original testimonials issued by the educational board and university. Upon receiving the mail, the colleague in question approached me, asking what would happen if he did not comply. I informed him that there would be a salary stop notice until the end of the verification process, as a week's time was considered more than sufficient.

After two days, the individual came to my room (guest house) late in the evening, even though we were still in the office. He confessed to me that his graduation qualification was fake. He had joined the company as a junior staff with an intermediate qualification and had been gradually promoted to an executive level based on his performance, but he had not provided his graduation certificate apart from mentioning it on his resume. This discrepancy was managed internally as part of the HR department.

I asked him who, besides himself, knew that he was not a graduate. He disclosed the name of a person who might have forwarded the complaint, possibly due to not being promoted as expected, stemming from personal enmity. We also sent a mail to the staff member (disclosed by my subordinate) to produce his original testimonials, and in response, he provided documents that were found to be false by the concerned university. As a result, the second person was terminated after 18 years of service.

The first person submitted a genuine letter from the university registrar, explaining that they needed more time to issue the certificate due to records being damaged in a super cyclone in 1999. For the time being, they provided a provisional certificate. Therefore, the first person survived for two reasons: (1) having testimonials up to intermediate level but no graduation certificate or information about the university, and (2) tactfully arranging an original letter from the university registrar along with a provisional certificate and CLC.

Hence, background verification can be conducted by the employer at any stage and is legal.

Regards, Prabhat

[Phone Number Removed For Privacy-Reasons]