Dear Srinath,
I do believe in the statement "the purpose of these discussions is not to achieve agreement but to generate dialogue and hence further our understanding of the issues." Hence, thanks for challenging my views.
When I wrote that most members of this forum are young, I did not mean to underestimate any member's seniority. Still, I feel that the right place for this query is one of the groups on LinkedIn and not Citehr.
You have given four parameters of measurement. However, Key Result Areas (KRAs) on these parameters can only be decided by the board of directors and no one else.
Today, the falling market share is the number one challenge for the newly appointed CEO of Nokia. Obviously, this factor will overshadow any other factor.
CEOs are selected based on the challenges of the market. When Carol Bartz joined Yahoo in 2006, her task was cut out - to increase revenue from the search engine and take on the competition with Google. But at that time, the challenges of the CEO of their rival, Google, were quite different.
"First, appoint the CEO and then tell the juniors to frame the KRAs" is nothing but ridiculous in plain language. Furthermore, Clara has asked for the duties and responsibilities of the CEO as well.
Possibly, we need to enumerate here the duties and responsibilities of the board members. Everything else is secondary at this moment.
Thanks,
Dinesh V Divekar