Facing PF Transfer Issues? How to Tackle Employer Deduction Errors and Rejections

I had withdrawn my company CPF. After that, I requested to transfer my PF from company B to C. The first time it got rejected, stating the claim was rejected. I raised a ticket in EPFO and explained that I have not withdrawn company B PF and I'm requesting its transfer. I submitted the transfer again, and now it's rejected stating:

1) Wrong EPS deductions made by the employer. Clarification required whether EPS/non-EPS member.
2) Claim already settled.

What do I need to do now?

If you withdrew your PF already, the account would be closed. So how are you planning to transfer your PF balance from B to C?