Dear Chaithanya,
Performance issues and termination of employment
Performance issues are among the various modes of termination of employment. In such cases, the method of discharge simpliciter is mostly adopted by employers. This method has the two-fold advantage of a non-stigmatic exit for the employee, thus not affecting their future employment prospects elsewhere, and the ease of eliminating an underperformer for the employer by simply adopting the exit clause of the contract of employment. However, the inherent danger of this simple method of termination is that it is as judicially questionable as the dismissal of an employee related to any behavioral issue. Therefore, it requires granting reasonable opportunities to the underperformer, such as placing them on a PIP and thoroughly documenting the employee's performance, the opportunities given for improvement, objective appraisals, and the absence of possible alternatives.
Redundancy and retrenchment
Redundancy is one of the reasons for retrenchment, which has to be strictly based on seniority in service, i.e., last come, first go, apart from strict compliance with the provisions of Section 25-F of the IDA, 1947. In this method of termination, there is no room for pick and choose; otherwise, the retrenchment would be illegal and treated as void ab initio.
COVID-19 lockdown implications
In the context of the COVID-19 lockdown promulgated under the blanket powers vested with the Government of India as per the Disaster Management Act, 2005, companies/employers are obligated not to terminate employees, including contract employees, during the lockdown period. It is a punishable offense with imprisonment of up to 6 months or two years with a fine under Section 188 of IPC or 51(b) of the DMA, 2005, respectively, as the case may be.
In my opinion, the best practice fitting the situation is to postpone the decision of terminating any underperformer or redundant employees for now.