Disagreement on EDLI and PF Contributions
I have a disagreement with Pan Singh on the following:
1. Higher Payments for EDLI
For the calculation of EDLI, the salary can be subjected to a maximum of Rs 15,000. This means there is no need to pay EDLI for the entire Rs 36,000.
2. Reducing PF Contributions
Once you start depositing PF on a higher salary, you cannot reduce it. However, you can reduce it to Rs 15,000, provided the employees agree. The PF authorities cannot demand that since you have been contributing PF on Rs 36,000, you should continue to deposit it on Rs 36,000, and you cannot reduce it to Rs 15,000. PF authorities cannot say that in such cases section 12 of the Act, which says that the employer cannot reduce the wages in order to reduce their PF contribution. In Maratwada Gramin Bank's case, the Apex Court has ruled that the PF Organisation has no authority to require the employer to contribute PF on a salary above Rs 6,500 (at the time the limit was 6,500, and therefore, you can make it 15,000 now).
In CTC terms, as the contribution payable by the employer is shown as part of the total remuneration, reducing the contribution will lead to a reduction in the remuneration of employees. Therefore, without taking the employees into confidence, you should not do that. In the case of workers (who are covered by the Industrial Disputes Act), notice as per section 9A will also be required to be served before enforcing such changes.
Regards, Madhu.T.K