Since they have already withdrawn the PF accumulations and closed the accounts, they are not existing members of the Provident Fund. Therefore, if they join a new company or the same company where they were previously employed, they should be treated as new employees. If their salary (considering PF qualifying components like Basic and DA) exceeds Rs 6,500, they can be treated as excluded employees. You may write to the PF Enforcement Officer who, I believe, has verbally ordered you to include them, despite them having already withdrawn their PF accumulations and no longer being PF members upon rejoining.
Clarification on Previous Employment and PF Membership
In this regard, one more clarification is required. If they were employed for more than 10 years in your company during their previous service period, then the situation would be different. If so, they would have withdrawn the Provident Fund only, and for the Pension Fund, they would have received a Scheme Certificate. This certificate is expected to be surrendered when they join another company (or return to the same company). Upon rejoining now, they are expected to be covered by PF regardless of their salary.
Regards,
Madhu.T.K