How Can Illusions Lead to Unsafe Acts and Accidents? Exploring the Connection

Kesava Pillai
Understanding Illusion and Its Impact on Accidents

Perception is the midway process between sensing and behavior. It is the process by which we understand the stimulus, interpret its meaning, and modify our behavior. This interpretation is largely determined by past experience.

Illusion is a false perception.

With a machine, output depends solely on input and is predictable. However, with humans, even if the input (stimulus) remains the same, behavior may differ. This is because human perception varies from person to person, time to time, and condition to condition. This variability is important in accident prevention.

For illusions, there are many causes. The energy available for sensing, such as radiation for seeing, mechanical for hearing and touching, and chemical for smelling and tasting, plays a role. Cognizance also significantly influences perception and illusion.

For example, a man in dim light may perceive a snake on the aisle and jump, falling into a ditch. Another person with a torch may see the same object as a piece of rope and either kick it or move it aside.

An illusion may lead to unsafe behavior, and unsafe behavior can cause accidents. This is the relationship between illusion and accident prevention.

Regards,
Kesava Pillai
dipil
Dear Sir,

Thank you for the simplest explanation. Do you have any case study of an industrial accident in which illusion comes as a contributory reason? If so, please share the same for a better understanding of the concept.

Incident Investigation and Recommendations

Suppose after a particular incident investigation, it was found that illusion was one of the contributory reasons for that incident. What recommendations must we suggest to avoid the re-occurrence? How can we ensure the parallel implementation of these recommendations among all the working crew, as "perception of men differs - from person to person, time to time, and condition to condition"?

Case Study: Illusion as a Contributory Factor

I would like to share an incident in which this illusion may be one of the contributory reasons. I think so. Need clarification. One person was engaged in poking material in a hopper through a poking hole of diameter 100mm. During this work, suddenly, a few materials flashed out through the opening. By seeing this, he thought the amount of material flashed out was high and jumped from the platform, resulting in an injury to his foot. He did not consider what the maximum material that could flash through a 100mm hole.

Please give your valuable comments on the above incident. What are the reasons you identify, and what suggestions should we give to avoid the recurrence of such incidents?

Regards,

Dipil Kumar V
Babu Alexander
I do not think it is an illusion.

1) The worker has not been given proper training in the operation of the machine.

2) The feed table is placed too high; proper guarding should have been provided for the worker to prevent jumping and potential injuries.

3) The worker, I presume, is in the 'line of fire'; any material backfall would certainly create anxiety for the worker due to assumption or past experience. When using a hopper for feeding where the likelihood of backfall exists, there should be an operator-controlled switch near their workplace to prevent such occurrences.

The above points are based on the details provided by you. However, upon actual observation, there are other factors to consider, such as the operator's height in relation to the feed table and hopper.

The best approach is to observe the operation for ten minutes; you may identify numerous unsafe behaviors or conditions.

Regards,
Babu Alexander
[Phone Number Removed For Privacy Reasons]
rtraman
Ensuring Consistent Implementation of Recommendations

I am copying the question from Mr. Dipils' write-up: "How can we ensure the parallel implementation of these particular recommendations among all the working crew, as 'perception of men differs - from person to person, time to time, and condition to condition'?"

Counseling and training have been identified as tools to bring different persons in a work area to the same level so that their reaction to a particular situation is more or less of the same pattern. Although achieving the ideal condition where everyone reacts in a similar way is not possible, training can help bridge the differences and develop the skills where people can react in the desired safe manner.

Best Regards,
Raman.
dipil
Thanks a lot for your reply to my query. Surely, counseling and training are the tools we can use to change a person's behavior. In the starting thread, Keshav Pillai pointed out an example of an illusion where a person mistook a piece of rope for a snake, leading to a jump and an accident. In this case, can counseling and training help? Can they ensure that the same person does not repeat the same wrong perception? In this particular example, I believe this incident occurred due to poor visibility, and the recommendation should be to increase illumination. Perhaps, illusion may be a contributory cause that cannot be entirely eliminated, with the root cause being the lack of illumination.

I look forward to hearing more views on illusions from other members. Once again, I request anyone with a case study of an industrial accident where illusion was a cause to please share it.

Regards,
Dipil Kumar V
If you are knowledgeable about any fact, resource or experience related to this topic - please add your views. For articles and copyrighted material please only cite the original source link. Each contribution will make this page a resource useful for everyone. Join To Contribute