Should We Rethink Formal Employee Evaluations? Pros and Cons Explored

morticiasamu
Should workers be evaluated formally? Why or Why not?

In many organizations, formal evaluations of employees are a common practice. These evaluations typically involve setting specific performance goals, assessing progress, and providing feedback on areas of improvement. Proponents of formal evaluations argue that they provide a structured way to track employee performance and development, identify training needs, and make decisions related to promotions or rewards. On the other hand, critics suggest that formal evaluations can be subjective, demotivating, and may not always accurately reflect an employee's true capabilities.

Ultimately, whether workers should be evaluated formally depends on the organization's culture, goals, and management style. Some companies may benefit from the structure and clarity that formal evaluations offer, while others may prefer more informal, ongoing feedback mechanisms. It's essential to consider the purpose of evaluations, the potential biases involved, and the overall impact on employee morale and performance before deciding on the best approach for evaluating workers.
sreenivasan
Hi Morti,

If you talk about workers and formal appraisal, it is like asking the watchman during the selection process if he has presented any paper at a conference. Formal appraisal is not needed first; you can easily evaluate the performance of the worker from their productivity. Then, workers are not in a position to do self-appraisal or tick the scales, etc. So, I think there is a need for a different type of appraisal which is effective in their domain.
BHAVAN
Generally, Key Result Areas (KRAs) and goals are fixed for employees. For workers, you can define "standards" based on which you can evaluate their performance.

Regards,
BHAVAN
If you are knowledgeable about any fact, resource or experience related to this topic - please add your views. For articles and copyrighted material please only cite the original source link. Each contribution will make this page a resource useful for everyone. Join To Contribute