Dear Sir,
Excellent discussion.
Regards,
Asha Manjunath 🤔
Hello RGS:
"I am not suggesting competence and effectiveness are one and the same, but I surely would like to say that generally with competence comes effectiveness."
Competence with talent brings effectiveness.
Competence is required for job success, but it is not sufficient.
"I do understand there's a common misconception that a person's skill is his talent."
I agree.
"Skills, however, are not talents."
I agree.
"Talents, on the other hand, require skills, I believe."
I disagree since a person can have excellent job talent yet be incompetent.
People can have skills and knowledge in areas where their talents do not lie.
Yes, and all too often people are in jobs that do not require their talent—these are bad hires.
"STEPHEN COVEY says if people have jobs that require their skills but not their talent, their organizations can never tap into their passion or voice."
I agree, but then again, that is my business.
"So, fire and motivation must come from within to bring out the best."
I agree, and when a person has the fire and motivation for the job, he may have the talent for the job.
"An employee may have the KSA's, but if the actual application doesn't take place to carry out the assigned task, then it surely amounts to incompetence, isn't it?"
We can be competent yet perform poorly due to our lack of talent.
"There is a mismatch here in terms of the job, person, as well as competencies. Do you agree?"
Yes.
"This is where a good number of managers falter in Recruitment and Selection and end up selecting employees to perform tasks that do not suit their competencies, resulting in dissatisfaction leading to high attrition rates."
Managers do a good job of screening out incompetent job applicants so they hire competent employees. What they don't do is differentiate between competent applicants who have job talent and those that don't have job talent. They hire both types and then complain that many new hires are less than successful.