Dear Nathrao,
Your contribution is well appreciated by me. Only to elaborate what you said, I had given the quote of mine as given in my earlier post in the thread. But the same quote is deleted due to may be some technical reason. The said quote is reproduced hereunder:
"The services rendered to members are domestic in nature like operating lift, water supply, electricity, cleaning, sweeping and security. Even repairs and maintenance is domestic in nature according to me. These services are essential for the very existence safety and security of the members of society and building of society. These services, therefore are in nature of personal services and can not be said to be economic activity. Such services as contended by itself would not make the society as a “shop”. (Ref. ESIC Vs. Tulsiani Chambers HC Mum 2008 LLR 362)"
Your contribution is well appreciated by me. Only to elaborate what you said, I had given the quote of mine as given in my earlier post in the thread. But the same quote is deleted due to may be some technical reason. The said quote is reproduced hereunder:
"The services rendered to members are domestic in nature like operating lift, water supply, electricity, cleaning, sweeping and security. Even repairs and maintenance is domestic in nature according to me. These services are essential for the very existence safety and security of the members of society and building of society. These services, therefore are in nature of personal services and can not be said to be economic activity. Such services as contended by itself would not make the society as a “shop”. (Ref. ESIC Vs. Tulsiani Chambers HC Mum 2008 LLR 362)"