Labour Law & Hr Consultant
Nagarkar Vinayak L
Hr And Employee Relations Consultant
Freelancer In Hr &indirect Taxes For
Insolvency N Gst Professional

Cite.Co is a repository of information and resources created by industry seniors and experts sharing their real world insights. Join Network
Recently I have joined in new company and management has instructed to remove 5 to 6 security employees who are on roll from more than 3 years, and company likely to be deployed new other contract security.
From India, Pune
Are the security personnel on contract? What are the terms and conditions in the contract? Removal or cessation of contract will have to be done as per signed agreement.
From India, Pune
Dear Rajesh,
I infer two things from your post - may be from the point of view of your boss.
One is testing your HR knowledge related to hiring and firing of people in the interest of the management free of any legal hassle. If not, the second one is to ascertain your capability to implement the change desired by the management in staffing pattern. Therefore, you have to handle the situation with utmost caution.
Once employed on regular basis in an organization whether it is industrial or otherwise, every employee earns a statutory right to security of tenure of his employment. It can't be simply taken away by the employer as and when he changes his hiring policy. If the employer wants to switch over to indirect methods of employment like contract labor system, FTC employment alternatively in respect of any category of existing job positions occupied by regular employees, such a move, apart from being unethical, would lead to industrial unrest or Disputes. As a HR manager, how you handle it by protecting both the interests of the management as well as the employees likely to be affected would be an acid test to your crisis management skills. You can not work out the economic gains of this change over as expected by your management in isolation : rather the cost of terminating the regular security personnel in a sudden and single go has also to be considered without fail. The psychological impact of such a move likely to create on the morale of other regular employees in the organization has also to be simultaneously considered.
Therefore, as a first step on your part , ensure that you have politely brought out all these procedural bottle necks to the notice of your boss before implementation. Second, either formally with the prior permission of the management or informally, you may initiate a dialougue with the concerned employees and assess the possibility of a voluntary separation with additional terminal benefits.
Of course, the final decision is with the management only. But there should be no complaints later that you failed to bring the consequences to the notice of the management or handled the situation so haphazardly to the disadvantage of or disrepute to the organization.

From India, Salem
Dear Colleague,
On plain reading, your management wants to reduce labour cost. Such drastic step if taken will have unpleasant repercussions and backlash .
You make your management aware that you cannot terminate permanent workers by replacing them with contract workers which will be patently illegal.
I share same views expressed by Mr Umakanthan sir.
Keeping the win win solution in the mind, you may think of proposing:
1. Alternate suitable job opportunity within the organisation to them.
2. Golden handshake scheme
3. Making them accept the separation package in exchange of working as contract security staff on lower salary.
Legally even the path of retrenchment ( if applicable) will be prohibitively difficult.
I know the above suggestions are not easy to convince your management but that is where lies your challenge.
Vinayak Nagarkar
HR- Consultant

From India, Mumbai
Umakant sir has focused on right solution.
When on rolls of company the guards were probably enjoying all the social security protection and benefits.Now that Under contract also they would be enjoying similar benefits.Therefore the reason as to why shift them on contract.
If they are not performing well then management can arrange to train them.
If any other reason like skip benifits of long term services or cost cutting or removal etc.then it is to be done with amicable settlement and without hampering their earning.

From India, Vadodara
Sir Thanks. But management has already decided to remove permanent security, they want to know my strategy .
I suggested that it is not possible because they are working from more than 3 years. only we can adjust them in our plant to work anywhere.
Rajesh C.

From India, Pune
Please send the latest minimum wages notification of Maharashtra, 2018
From India, Pune
Sir,visit www.punedistrict security guard
Under rates tag you will find it.However if any query related to guard board pls write at .

From India, Vadodara
Dear Sirs,
I have recently joined in a new Ayurved company, now Company wants to make me as Factory Manager after 6 months, Company has decided to shift existing Factory Manager on any other location due to some complaint. existing Factory Manager is from last 18 years.
Myself how can set up. Kindly advice.
Rajesh C.

From India, Pune
This discussion thread is closed. If you want to continue this discussion or have a follow up question, please post it on the network.
Add the url of this thread if you want to cite this discussion.

About Us Advertise Contact Us
Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service

All rights reserved @ 2020 Cite.Co™