Dinesh Divekar
Business Mentor, Consultant And Trainer
Partner - Risk Management
Ed Llarena, Jr.
Owner/ Managing Partner
Insolvency N Gst Professional
Retired From Air India
Sr. Manager Hr
+3 Others

Cite.Co is a repository of information and resources created by industry seniors and experts sharing their real world insights. Join Network
Dear Members,
One of my friend has recently joined one real estate company in Mumbai which is 50 year old organization. All employees in the company are very senior working with organization from 10-25 year. They all are either 10 or 12 passed only. Hardly a few have done some diploma courses in engineering.
Most of the senior employees does not have their education certificate.
My friend is first HR hired in the organization in past 50 years. There are new hired too in the organization now sine my friend has joined. They all are well educated & have done many diploma courses.
Now management has asked my friend to set salary & designation for all employees. Here my friend has asked for my help.
I am really very much confused how to do this coz old employees, but no educational certificates. New comer well educated with lots of professional courses. How to justified both.
I need your support & guidance to help my friend.
Warm Regards

Dear Ravita,

Thekedar-Munshiji culture is the mainstay of construction companies of India. It appears that your friend's company has practiced it to the core. In fact what was the logic of recruiting HR is not understood. If the management could run their company without HR for the last 50 long years then they can very well do so for the next 50 years as well. How come this sudden realisation that businesses require HR too?

Bringing change in such organisations is very difficult. This is because companies of this kind run like mafia. As such in India, construction business is more run because of nexus with politicians, government officials and so on. Who cares about the knowledge of the civil engineering or the world-class construction standards? Recent collapse of the bridge in Kolkata is case in point.

In the company where your friend is working, personal allegiance overrides professionalism. Against this backdrop, find out from your friend what HR interventions are acceptable to his boss. This is because, any intervention would need support from the management and also from the people. Second challenge would be the direct dealing with the boss. Your friend is a newbie. At least for HR matters, top boss should not bypass your friend. Your friend's challenge is double-fold. One is that people lack of requisite qualification and second one is personal loyalty developed out of the long stay. Value addition from HR will come provided your friend has sufficient empowerment. Else his role would be to become yet another yes-person of the flock of yes-persons.


Dinesh Divekar

Dear Ravita,
It is a very big challenge for your friend. He has to maintain a balance between experience and qualification. You can not ignore experience for the sake of qualification and you can not ignore qualification for the sake of experience. Since changing the traditional work style of the company is difficult, the criteria here should be experience and then qualification. However, to maintain equilibrium consider qualification for experience depending on the talent and skill of the person. A professional approach is vefy difficult in this case as your friend may not necessarily get support of Management.

Designations, is something the owners have to take a call on.
You should make an organisation chart first to help them decide who,should do what and report to whom.
The line and staff positions should be separated and the dotted line reporting should also be clear.
About salary, first you need to see what market will pay. If you try to,pay new people what the old ones are getting most will probably leave pretty soon. But you also need to try and keep the salary same for new and old employees for same function. The new have qualification and the old have experience, both of which you need. Then you should set up a performance evaluation system. The salary scale up should be based on that. The salary differential will start coming in as the performance and achievements filter in
Of course, at each step, and for the grand long term plan, you need to ensure that your owner has a birds eye view and approves of your approach

Dear ravi
Tell to your friend that
Give more importance to seniors who have worked for last more than 15 years
You fix the salary according to
1.Seniority & education
2.Education Highest level
3.Seniority no education

As rightly pointed out by our Seniors ; 50 yr old Co. running with 20-25 yrs. expd. employees; now attempting to give Designations, fixing salaries based on Qflcn, Exp. etc.,is a Sensitive issue especially; if the no.of employees are more. It will pose a great heart burning if all are not convinced/satisfied about their post & pay & anomalies are bound to happen.
A thurough study of the existing employees Qlfcn., exp. etc., tobe reviewed & appropriate Designations & pay scale/payband with yrly increment etc., tobe considered. It is a hurricane job & expert in the same field can be requisitioned to solve the problem once for all.
Sooner it is done, the better it is for Co.Management, Employees & HR Head. WISH U GOOD LUCK.
HR Consultant 5.4.16

How well is your company doing in the industry as compared to peers in the same field?
What is the existing pay structure?
Are they on par with other firms in same business/?
How many qualified employees v/s experienced employees?
In construction business,experience plays a vital role for successful implementation of projects.
A supervisor who has come up using brick and mortar may sometimes be more knowledgeable than a degree holding/diploma engineer who is all theory but no practise.
So do not just go by mere degrees etc.
Matter needs to be fully discussed with the boss.
The boss should be in line with your thought processes.
Before you go to boss-do a lot of home work like designations,job requirements,descriptions and organisation chart.
Sensitive and careful dealings will be most important to prevent sudden heartburns and departures.

Thank You So Much Mr. Nathrao for your suggestion.
Well the company does not stand among Top builders in Mumbai I mean is not well known but still have a good report because of its legacy & good work. Employee strength in the organization is approx 80.
90% of employees are old (In terms of years of working) having 15-30 years of experience. Mostly employees are SSC & HSC. Package is not as per top companies but is equal to Mid level organizations.
An MBA holder with 9 years exp getting what salary , the same is paid to seniors who have done HSC with 20 years exp. Designation for both too is same.
There the conflict can be !!

MBA with 9 years experience-now in which field,what is he employed on in the company,is it correspondence or fun time MBA-these type of information would be required to decide.

Weightage to seniority and qualifications will have to be worked out.

I would initially give experience a higher weightage.

Conflict can be reduced but not avoided in this situation.

Some new employees may leave or even older employees.

Be prepared for this fallout.

Move forward after discussion with top bosses and keep them in the loop about likely fallout and whether they are ready to face it.

Omelette cannot be made without breaking eggs.

End result of change should be that organisation is more ready to face competition.

New blood will be more ready to face change,older lot may be in traditional mode and say-we do things this way-which may not be suitable for modern and competitive times.

Task is tough but with clear ideas,compromises and alternative ideas it can be achieved.

may not be possible to have total revamp at one go,but process of revamping can begin and seeing outcome carry on,make changes etc.

Dear Ravita,
As a first job, what you and your friend need to do is to make proper organisation chart. Unless you make this chart, there is no point in deciding about the salaries. There has to be clarity as to who reports to whom. Then you need to find out whether a case where junior has more salary than senior in the same department. You need to fix these issues first.
The next thing is about measures of performance standards. Salary is also based on the ability to meet desired level of performance. Rewarding length of service is dangerous. That anyway your employers did hitherto. You cannot continue this practice ad infinitum.
Dinesh Divekar

This discussion thread is closed. If you want to continue this discussion or have a follow up question, please post it on the network.
Add the url of this thread if you want to cite this discussion.

About Us Advertise Contact Us
Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service

All rights reserved @ 2020 Cite.Co™