Dear Seniors,
Is it legal if employer put restrictions on maternity benefit upto 2 children only. Becasue there is no any such provision in maternity benefit act for such restrictions.
Thanks inbanticipation....

From India, Pune
Harsh Kumar Mehta

Consultant in Labour Laws/HR
Sir, The restriction, if any, imposed by the employer on his employees without having legal sanction, in my opinion, will be void and illegal ab initio.
From India, Noida
Dear Mehta sir, Generally state and centralngovernment put such restrictions to their employees for availing benefits. that is why the question.
From India, Pune
Harsh Kumar Mehta

Consultant in Labour Laws/HR

1. You are correct so far as restrictions imposed on Government employees is concerned. The Governments are entitled to impose any policy of small family norms on their employees by enacting service conditions viz. The Fundamenal Rules etc.

2. However, there appears to be no such restrictions so far as Maternity Benefit Act and ESI Act, 1948 are concerned. The reasons may be that these enactments affect a large number of working population and furthermore by virtue of their contributions (ESI Act) they become entitled for maternity benefit. There may also be reasons that payment of maternity benefit under these Acts has no effect on financial resources of the Governments. However, in respect of "Confinement Expenses" [which is paid by ESIC under Rule 56-A of ESI (Central) Rules, 1950], which are paid to insured woman and the wife of insured persons there is restrictions of "two confinements only".

3. If in future the legislature want to put any restrictions in above Acts, then certainly it will be at par with the facilities available to Governments employees. However, in that case such restrictions may be having the force of law.

From India, Noida

Asso.Prof.(Commerce & Management)
The matter is of one many important provisions of law, persons in HR field should know with an analytical approach in order to appreciate the realty vis--vis implementation of ones own HR policy, the Maternity Act and general health of the women involved. No one will have any doubt in agreeing women folks are the most affected human in a pragnancy, pre-natal and post natal and there after. And any restrictions, curtailment in passing on Maternity benefits to her naturally affect her very badly whatsoever the basis for imposing such curtailments. There are more than one factor/arises in implementing the restrictions and curtailments, they are which are to be read w.r.t. provisions of MA & ESI Act

1. What are the norms and how they account for restrictions vis-a-vis the Laws

2. Is it on No.of confinements or on No.of children she bears/delivers

3. Is it limited to the payment of maternity benefits only or other important provisions with regard to Maternity leave, child care relaxations, fighting malnourishment, health of the mother and

4. her relevance in bringing up the surviving children

5. and job security of the mother in certain specified employments /establishments so on

I wish to quote /refer the Judgment of the Madras High Court (2009) in the matter of extending Maternity Benefits passed by Learned Mr. Justice (Rtd) K. Chandru, (whom I admire most as the one of very few judges of our generation who meant Justice and it should also be speedy) who had touched upon many relevant provisions from various Acts in this judgment. I failed to cullout some of his views to fit them here in order to make this short, but every word of his found to be apt and hence his shorter version of judgment is attached for our members to appreciate his views in the matter. Further I also extracted and quote here relevent portions from another judgment of the SC (though related to woman casual labour) ..

Going by these references I only wish to say its not justifiable to discriminate woman folks based on the status of employment or on No.of confinements & children, or place of posting etc. in the matter of extending Maternity benefits including grant of leave and monetary issues, post natal difficulties, child & mother care etc.

From India, Bangalore

Attached Files
File Type: docx Maternity Act,FR Vs.Small Family Norms-Madras High Court.docx (27.3 KB, 452 views)
File Type: docx SC Judgment-Maternity benefit to woman on MusterRoll.docx (27.2 KB, 243 views)
File Type: docx Maternity Act-citeHR-The matter is of one the important matters persons in HR field should know.docx (20.9 KB, 358 views)


Now freelance consultant in Labour law/HR
There is no restriction,as per MB Act or ESI Act. Varghese Mathew
From India, Thiruvananthapuram
This discussion thread is old and is closed for new comments. If you want to continue this discussion or have a follow up question, please post a new thread. Add the url of this thread if you want to cite this discussion.

About Us Advertise Contact Us
Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service

All rights reserved @ 2021 Cite.Co