I'm working as a HR Executive for past 1+ yrs.. I've done my Engineering in E&C and after that did my MBA(HR) thro' DDE. Actually i had a passion to do MBA.. But now whereever i go for interview they are asking me " Why MBA after BE?? - both are different streams ".. i used to answer them saying that "i wanted to enter into management side as i have so much interest and passion towards it and i chose HR since i like interacting with people"...
But i find nobody is satisfied with my answer eventhough it is the truth..
Can citehr friends help me in answering this question in a professional way.. It will be of greater help..
Swati :)
11th September 2007 From India, Bangalore

Hr Professtional
Mechanical Desgn Engineer
Sr.executive Hrd
Hr Executive
Hr Executive-recruitment
Vivek Chandrasekar
Business Executive
Engineering Student
+8 Others

It is good that you had done MBA after BE
So better to apply in some core companies of ur enginnering background
where you can apply ur knowledge also.
And those peoples well understand why MBA after BE , and dont ask such questions
Best Of luck
11th September 2007 From India, Mumbai
Dear Swathi,
One thing I would like to know, are you looking at your furure in HR or want to settle down as Engineer
Because as per your say you are working as an Executive HR, why don't you try out as an IT Recruiter, which I feel is apt for your academics & moreover you want be a people person.
What Say.
11th September 2007 From India, Hyderabad
Hi Swathi

Even my academic BG is same as u(BE EC ,MBA HR&Systems).Even I faced the same questions.

What I feel is tell what actually happened in ur case.In my case I was not so sure on my goal or target while I was doing BE.Just I did it to become an engineer...even my parents and relatives had influence on that.But b4 finishing the course i started doing reserch on the current industry and career options....and matched with my present skill sets.I found my self in a better way doing managerial kind of job,interacting with people,making decisions,helping and motivating others and able to convince others.....I realy enjoy doing this kind of this.....I have a few examples to justify this...always state things with examples supporting that...Now I am very clear on what I can do and what I have to do...

Technical knowledge will help to do technical interviews,interacting with engineers,understand ther requirements,technical recruitment,performance appraisals in IT COMPANIES .......its always an asset to have technical backgrnd.

:) praveen
11th September 2007 From India
Hi Swati,
You can support your thought with the following answers:
1) In India when we are 18yrs, we do not really understand what we really want to be. By Merit we get whatever we deserve or whatever our parents think is the best for us. After we spend 3-4yrs we get to know what would be expected out of us after we complete this professional course. But do we really want to pursue the same? or is it something else that would be more exciting? and you end up finding Management more fascinating than E&C Engineering.
2) How many Engineering graduates every year end up with really doing what they studied? Majority (infact more than 80%) enter the Software Engineering field though they come from EEE, E&C,Mechanical,Chemical etc.,and they are welcome. So, why not after BE, do MBA and enter Management...
11th September 2007 From India, Mumbai
I completely agree with praveen practical support..
i think u better opt for MNC where you can deal with man power planning so that you can use ur skills in implementing technical support as well as hr management...
11th September 2007 From India, Mumbai
Dear Swati,
BE + MBA is a lethal combination to have for the Corporate World.
I am surprised that people ask you this question and are not satisfied with the answers.
You may tell them:"BE has enhanced my logical and analytical abilities. MBA gives me the whole picture of how an organization works. MBA is a practitioners degree and BE gives me a sound base to adapt, adopt and understand domain knowledge quickly to apply the same for Corporate Growth".
Sunil Chandra
11th September 2007 From India, Gurgaon
Hi Swathi,
The questions posed at the interview are just to check your attitude and reasoning ability, there is no hard and fast rule that a BE GRADUATE cannot pursue an MBA,
Be it a B.com MBA, or a BE MBA, what counts is your practical learning in the organisation,
Make sure that every action you take is a new learning experience for you.
keep updating yourself with emerging tends
Thanks and Regards
12th September 2007 From India, Mumbai
Hi Praveen, Sonu, Sunil and everyone.. Thanks for ur suggestions and replies..
My situation was the same as Praveen said.. When i passed out my school like others even me and my parents wanted me to do BE.. we had a paper called 'Entrepreneur Management' during my 1st Year.. Actually i got the inspiration of doing MBA only during that Period.. and moreover i thought BE with MBA will be an added value to my career.. But when i started getting such questions i was taken li'l aback.. But all your replies had made me happy and i've the confidence that i can easily take the question in any interview. :)
12th September 2007 From India, Bangalore
Hi Now ur confident right???and u have the answer with u ....tell the same thing to interviewers....All the best...Inform us when the good things happens in ur career :) Cheers Praveen
12th September 2007 From India

Share what you know with your industry peers. Discuss problems, ideas, solutions openly without getting into company or personal specifics. Create Account

Disclaimer: This network and the advice provided in good faith by our members only facilitates as a direction. The advice should be validated by proper consultation with a certified professional. The network or the members providing advice cannot be held liable for any consequences, under any circumstances.

About Us - Advertise - Contact Us - RSS   On Google+  
Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Terms Of Service
Facebook Page | Follow Us On Twitter | Linkedin Network