dipil
710

Dear Ahammad Frequency rate = 0.387596899 Severity rate = 1167.635659 Please go through the attachment for more details.
From India

Attached Files (Download Requires Membership)
File Type: xls FR & SR Calculation.xls (19.5 KB, 345 views)

Dear Sir,
thank you very much sir, my calculation is also like this. but our manager said in FR we must consider only LTI not fatal,then i have a doubt then i send a request to CiteHR.
thanks a lot sir
regards
Ahammad

From India, Hyderabad
dipil
710

Dear Mr. Ahammad

You should have give me a call before referring what I have been suggested/replied to you regarding FR... I got a call from one person from GDCL. I am not able to recollect his name. Whoever it is, if his intention is for clearing the concept / sharing knowledge I will welcome the same, but he seems to interested in conveying his ideas to me and make me agree with that.

For future also don't just blindly go behind the suggestions you getting through this forum... It may be wrong also... Most of the time when I am replying I make myself satisfied with the answer which I am posting, then come up with the response...

Now his arguments was following which I thought I should bring in front of the forum to get the view of others:

1. He is telling as LTI & Fatal is not same, we don't need to consider/count fatal accident while calculating the FR. Suppose if one LTI & one Fatal happened, as total number of one accident to be calculated for FR calculation.

I am still not agreeing with this.

Suppose in a plant if Two fatal accident happened and no LTI happened, will the frequency rate be "ZERO".

What is the logic behind such an argument.

Mr. Ahammadh, I request you to refer this website to your friend/manager who is arguing you on this subject. Let him come up with his input on this forum. If it is right and justifiable we will learn from it.

Comments awaiting from other members too.

From India
Dear Sir, I am not available from 23.01.13 to 27.01.13 due to Operation to my uncle.now i am available as per your suggestion i refer this website to my manager. thank you sir regards Ahammad
From India, Hyderabad
Anonymous
dear sir, if one phalanx of ring ringer or any finger was amputated then is this a LTI or MTI if it is LTI then there is any written evidence by gov authority
From India, Ludhiana
Dear All, Please give formula of FSI (Frequency-Severity Index). Kindly do needful.
From India, New Delhi
Very nice site for professional knowledge
From India, Murshidabad
Mr. Dipil Kumar Vasu As per your reply "Fatality is not treated as LTI", I cannot get this statement from Appendix A of IS 3786-1983. Can you tell me where it is. Nagarajan
From India, Mumbai
dipil
710

Hi Nagarajan,
In the Appendix A, no where it is written so. But how come this confusion arising?
Fatality means someone looses his/her life... Lost time injury means, he/she is still alive with injuries restricting normal working even after 48 hours of incident... The severity of injuries what differs..
Now for the calculation purpose, in Is:3786, you can see the number of man days lost to consider against Fatal and LTI's (Case of total disablement under Part A of Appendix A - restricting further employment of the individual) are 6000 days...
Further when you refer Part B - Partial disablement, other LTI's are mentioned with less number of man days lost to consider for the calculations...
Hope this helps.
Please feel free to write in case need more clarifications.

From India

If you are knowledgeable about any fact, resource or experience related to this topic - please add your views.








About Us Advertise Contact Us Testimonials
Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service

All rights reserved @ 2022 CiteHRŽ

All Material Copyright And Trademarks Posted Held By Respective Owners.
Panel Selection For Threads Are Automated - Members Notified Via CiteMailer Server