Ash Mathew
Recruitments, Training`
V. Balaji
Ir & Hr
Abhi16march
Manager Hr
PVQ
Human Capital Development Specialist
Avani Bhatnagar
Manager - Training & Hr
Tshanmugammba
Hr Professional
Anusuya Jana
Generalist
+7 Others

Cite.Co is a repository of information and resources created by industry seniors and experts sharing their real world insights. Join Network
Hi everyone,,
yesterday I was discussing with my HR friends,ie. communication b/w opposite sex in HR, ,and Impact of this..........
My quest is ....
which is more effective.....[if a HR is calling to the candidate for candidature( Interaction b/w the candidates and HR)....]
1.Male HR + female candidate
2.Female HR + Male candidate
3. Male HR + Male candidate
4.Female HR + Female candidate
Men and women definitely have different ways of communicating. ..Its human being if a male is interacting with female,his way of interaction will be definitely diff than a communicating with male.....decency level will be high,expression wil be diff r ........... & convincing b/w the diff sex is better than same sex..its my perception.....
I think,communication b/w different sex in Recruitment is one of the imp. tool .........
whats your view on this topic??

From India, Pune
Gentleman,
All this is problem of mind.
If you are male of female what knowledge and know how or competancies are important and not sex to whom you talk. This is 18th century thinking.
This question do not deserve place on this forum.
Partho

From Saudi Arabia
Gentleman,
This question is very much deserve for this forum,but one should have content for the discussion........and I dint get,why you told this, 18th centuray quest ..????this is based on human psychology man................anyway

From India, Pune
Hi Abhishek
The question which you posted is of real importance. Which to choose is a critical choice to be made. Sometimes people be gentle to the opposite sex and vice versa. But mostly it is the opposite sex which gains more respect, people seem to be more civil in their conversation with the other gender.
Thanks and Regards
Srithala Devi

From India, Madras
This issue is gender discrimination. Gender is not job specific therefore HR has limited scope to practice gneder base HR.
Moreover, any discrimination based on gender is an illegal according to US and Europian labour laws.
Partho

From Saudi Arabia
hi abhi.. i think ur predictions may not be correct in all d cases. we can take some people into your predicted group.. but every one wil not b same sorry 4 contradicting ur prediction kamal
From India, Hyderabad
dear friends,
Every human has the right to express his/her views. We must speakto express not to impress. Whether executive is male or female, let's see what matter is being discussed and not who is discussing this. Probably "accepting a person as what he or she is than what you are" attitude will help a health discussion!
V. Balaji

From India, Madras
Well according to my past experience I had given 4 interview at one go...out of which 3 were taken by females n one by the male...all 4 were equally good according to my point of view...I got selected in all the 3 interviews which were taken by females but the in the last one I was rejected by the male interviewee...so it not opposite sex which a plus or a negative point but many other thgs which helps in selecting/ rejecting the candidate...
From India, New Delhi
I agree with my collegue Partho. This forum does not require such articles . It depends on how sharp in their IQ but not sex B.Dakhsina murty HR Manager
From India, Hyderabad
Hi Abhi,

It differs from case to case.

Take for instance BPO - I have seen many campus recruitments where the girls dress "differently" that they usually are. Reason: They try to show their interesting culture which may attract a partuclar age group of people, and people with intentions of just - no matter what job, but needs glamour and fun around.

Take for instance Automotive industry - if its an initial tele discussion and if the candidate senses that the recruiter has no clue abt what the role is, in minutes he/she will hang up and leave

take civil - a tele-interview will not help you understand if he is fit or not. Some of the them *(in low level) may not be expressive while talking but may do an excellent job.

But if you are talking to a senior person in the construction Industry - and if the recruiter (Corp HR too) has less info abt projects, they will never prefer talking to the corpo hr, just emails....

Travel Industry - Really information savvvy people. They are fast, quick, smart, and hates a "stereo typed talk"

(Accountants - at mid and junior levels may not compliant against the stereo type..)

It differs in the Approach, definitely not in gender (excluding BPO)

Whatever the gender be, the recruiter has to possess every information abt the role and represent the company really well. It is also a part of branding.

From India, Madras

This discussion thread is closed. If you want to continue this discussion or have a follow up question, please post it on the network.
Add the url of this thread if you want to cite this discussion.






About Us Advertise Contact Us
Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms Of Service



All rights reserved @ 2020 Cite.Co™