Hi friends
Is it appropriate for one person to work under two different designations in the same company irrespective of the department?
Now this particular person in our company is handling responsibilities in two different department i.e.( Ex. Assistant to the Chairman of the company & Ex. Commercial Officer ).
Please provide your view on this subject
Warm Regards
Fay
From Kuwait
3Is it appropriate for one person to work under two different designations in the same company irrespective of the department?
Now this particular person in our company is handling responsibilities in two different department i.e.( Ex. Assistant to the Chairman of the company & Ex. Commercial Officer ).
Please provide your view on this subject
Warm Regards
Fay
From Kuwait
Well i dont agree with you , and hence i have raised this query.
If the person is capable, fine but what about the other capable who are equally smart enough, dnt you think they should be given a chance?
Regads
Fay
From Kuwait
If the person is capable, fine but what about the other capable who are equally smart enough, dnt you think they should be given a chance?
Regads
Fay
From Kuwait
Hi, In my view, if the person is competent to perform both the tasks, then it should not be a problem with the designatons.
From India, Mumbai
From India, Mumbai
This means there are companies having these type of designations? Can u guys give me some examples?
From Kuwait
From Kuwait
Hello,
Interesting question!
Of course the companies can do what they like. But that is NOT the question. Should the company decide to assign more than one function to the same individual? The answer will now depend upon the following factors.
But to analyse your proposition, a sound rationale supporting such a decision may change the response as different facts could even justify such a decision. But by and large, I recommend avoiding this kind of a situation in any organization.
Even when one grows out of the job of "Executive Assistant to Chairman" and handles an exclusive portfolio, he often finds others treating him "differently". This could complicate his performance too!
Your views please.
Regards
samvedan
June 26, 2008
-------------------------------------------------
From India, Pune
Interesting question!
Of course the companies can do what they like. But that is NOT the question. Should the company decide to assign more than one function to the same individual? The answer will now depend upon the following factors.
- Are the two functions aligned in the sense that there is possibility of conflict of functional interests?
- Are the two functions placed at different levels in the organizational hierarchy where the authority structures could upset performance of either of them or even of the other related functions?
- Is the individual in possession of necessary knowledge, skills, experience and professional maturity?
- What is so very important that the organization needs to ask the same individual to perform two dissimilar functions and be accountable for both?
But to analyse your proposition, a sound rationale supporting such a decision may change the response as different facts could even justify such a decision. But by and large, I recommend avoiding this kind of a situation in any organization.
Even when one grows out of the job of "Executive Assistant to Chairman" and handles an exclusive portfolio, he often finds others treating him "differently". This could complicate his performance too!
Your views please.
Regards
samvedan
June 26, 2008
-------------------------------------------------
From India, Pune
Hi
I agree with Sujata and Shiv, it all depends upon the capability of the employee and other factors related to it.
I presume, the designation shouldn't matter at all unless the organization is getting benefited. What is important is the learning and growth of both the organization and the individual.
From India, Hyderabad
I agree with Sujata and Shiv, it all depends upon the capability of the employee and other factors related to it.
I presume, the designation shouldn't matter at all unless the organization is getting benefited. What is important is the learning and growth of both the organization and the individual.
From India, Hyderabad
I think there are couple of things you need to answer and consider:
1)Are both these designations mentioned in the offer letter of a person?
2)Since how long is this person working in too roles?
There is a high possibility that this is a temporary arrangement made by the organization.
In some of the companies HR Manager is also asked to take the responsibilities of Administration or Facility Management; In some other small companies CFO or Finance Head is asked to take care of HR Department as well. Some companies appoint same person as a Chairman and Managing Director…I think all that matter is the size of the company and its financial status.
Do not take tensions about it.
Have a great weekend.
Thanks and Regards
Sanjeev
From India, Mumbai
1)Are both these designations mentioned in the offer letter of a person?
2)Since how long is this person working in too roles?
There is a high possibility that this is a temporary arrangement made by the organization.
In some of the companies HR Manager is also asked to take the responsibilities of Administration or Facility Management; In some other small companies CFO or Finance Head is asked to take care of HR Department as well. Some companies appoint same person as a Chairman and Managing Director…I think all that matter is the size of the company and its financial status.
Do not take tensions about it.
Have a great weekend.
Thanks and Regards
Sanjeev
From India, Mumbai
This kind of ARRANGEMENTS are more likely to be seen in small company where a you find a perosn not fully occupied in his core job hence tends to the job enlargement.
But same time if the same perosn will be aksed to play two different roles-then need to identify
Is there any nepotism going on?
Is perosn being paid double for two jobs?
or anyother organisational issues.
The private organisation have flexibilities to take such the decisions. I do not see any legal consequences of such action as long as the employee is doing both the job happyly.
From India, Bangalore
But same time if the same perosn will be aksed to play two different roles-then need to identify
Is there any nepotism going on?
Is perosn being paid double for two jobs?
or anyother organisational issues.
The private organisation have flexibilities to take such the decisions. I do not see any legal consequences of such action as long as the employee is doing both the job happyly.
From India, Bangalore
hi
he can be assigned with n no of responsibility but then dual designation should not exist. Basically this problems happen in an unorganised organisation where the Head himself doesn't know where he wants to take his company and what are the key perspective in employing professionals for the same.
sanjeev.
From India, Delhi
he can be assigned with n no of responsibility but then dual designation should not exist. Basically this problems happen in an unorganised organisation where the Head himself doesn't know where he wants to take his company and what are the key perspective in employing professionals for the same.
sanjeev.
From India, Delhi
Fay,
As most of our HR peers have mentioend, it happens in small organizations to save some cost as well as engage an individual to the fullest.
As long as employee is happy doing the job and management is fine with the productivity, it can continue.
As far as I know, it happens even in bigger organizations till someone is replaced.
Cheers,
Pradeep
From India, Hyderabad
As most of our HR peers have mentioend, it happens in small organizations to save some cost as well as engage an individual to the fullest.
As long as employee is happy doing the job and management is fine with the productivity, it can continue.
As far as I know, it happens even in bigger organizations till someone is replaced.
Cheers,
Pradeep
From India, Hyderabad
Community Support and Knowledge-base on business, career and organisational prospects and issues - Register and Log In to CiteHR and post your query, download formats and be part of a fostered community of professionals.
